Who will answer for negligence by the tax inspectorate?
Tax inspectors confirmed the right to property allowances, and returned personal income tax to taxpayers. However, later on it turned out that people received the allowance unlawfully. This did not occur by any fault of theirs, but because of mistakes made by tax revenue officer. Officials demanded that the taxes be returned, so people appealed to the Supreme Court. The court declared the personal income tax, which taxpayers received due to negligence on the part of revenue officers, unjust enrichment. In this case, revenue officers have the right to demand that the personal income tax be returned to the budget. The deadline is three years from the time that the decision to grant an allowance was made.
The Constitutional Court ruled that collecting taxes that were returned due to an allowance being mistakenly granted is permissible on the basis of provisions contained in the Russian Federation Civil Code concerning unjust enrichment (Supreme Court Resolution No. 9-P dated March 27,
2017).